Who's ready to read my not so spicy, not very hot take on the latest Mastodon Scraping deal?

I think it's ready!

Follow

On Scraping Mastodon:

If they hadn't misunderstood the difference between a name of a field and the social and cultural implications of it's usage, this paper wouldn't have been written.

medium.com/@maloki/on-scraping

This is a friend link, so you can read and share it as much as you like.

and a friendly reminder, to support people who post on Medium, you can either clap or look at their patrons / other ways to support them.

But if you have no money, but have a Medium account, the best thing you can do is clap on articles you like!

If you want to help this article spread, by boosting it on Twitter too here's the link:

twitter.com/kinkymal/status/12

@maloki If they'd got it right and obtained consent, a far more interesting paper could have been written...

@dumpling Too true. I feel like we could bring some people together on here, to actually write such a paper correctly. :D

@maloki that would be fun... Fediverse research, produced by the fediverse!

@maloki@elekk.xyz I wrote up a very nice retort to the paper along this line, but their journal appears to only have been a conference publication and not a regular publication that might publish retorts.

@aldersprig Yeah. It's a good retort, and I do not believe I was the only person who reached the conclusion.

I have like 20 tabs open that I wanted to link to, and credit, but my head forgot to go back to them (because it was a bit much)...

@maloki this is fantastic, thank you for writing it and sharing it!

@aparrish Thank you for reading it! I'm glad people like it, that impostor syndrome always tickles the back of your mind when you post stuff like this..

@maloki @aparrish Wtf they thought it was for inappropriate content?!!

@June @aparrish that's what they wrote. That was the basis for their entire paper. 😅 😂 🤣 😭

@June @maloki @aparrish if you thought your content was inappropriate for the place you were posting it, why would you post it in the first place???

@maloki @June @aparrish seems like this is less about a lack of cultural competence and more about a lack of general thinking skills

@maloki

1) well written. nicely done.

2) WTFOMGBBQ??? :flan_confused:​ I mean... WHAT???

I wish I was surprised. This whole 'research' *reeks* of "computer people doing utterly superficial research and thinking that they understand a topic." Which is endemic with this crowd.

Next up, they'll solve global warming with blockchain. :flan_set_fire:

@mwlucas seems it may not be peer reviewed or anything either, it's kinda funny :D

@maloki I was in the social sciences before and I find it maddening to see these computer science papers without any ethical considerations. You cannot start social research without ethical board approval. Cs: yolo let's scrape a network and and dump it online.

@maloki I wrote about this a while back and have some considerations on the ethics of online research coming from that background.

jonne.arjoranta.fi/2020/intern

@jaranta 👍
I wish I had seen it earlier.

I originally wanted to connect back to a lot of other people, but then my mind couldn't, so I left it out (mh/brain fog/adhd stuff).

@maloki well said. They should have got you to write their paper! Or rather, a different paper...

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Elekk: Mastodon for Gamers

The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!